Plant Trees SF Events 2005 Archive: 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021


50˘ of Every Tax Dollar Goes to Pay for Wars 
March 7 2005

Increasing numbers of Americans say the U.S. government is involved in 
immoral and illegal wars around the world and are refusing to support this 
with their tax money. The invasion and occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan 
and the indiscriminate killing of civilians, for example, are outlawed by
international law.

"Of every tax dollar paid, more than 50 cents goes to pay for past, present 
and future military expenses. The military budget for the Department of 
Defense alone for 2005 will be close to $500 billion. Our payment of 
federal taxes enables the government to carry on a continuing program of 
illegal military activities," wrote Glen Milner, a member of Ground Zero 
Center for Nonviolent Action in Poulsbo, Wash., in a recent opinion piece 
in The Seattle Post-Intelligencer.

"International laws and agreements support and encourage citizens to resist 
their government when it is engaged in illegal acts," Milner added.

Under international laws, those who facilitate illegal wars and war crimes 
could actually be morally ­if not legally­ accountable, say proponents of 
resisting war taxes. Principle IV of the Nuremberg Principles states: "The 
fact that a person acted pursuant to order of his government or of a 
superior does not relieve him from responsibility under international law, 
provided a moral choice was in fact possible to him."

For example, a 1996 ruling by the International Court of Justice regarding 
the threat or use of nuclear weapons could be interpreted to mean that the 
United States' deployment of depleted uranium weapons is illegal. The 
humanitarian measure prohibits the use of weapons or methods of warfare
that are directed against civilians or cannot discriminate between military 
targets and civilians; cause unnecessary suffering to combatants; violate 
the territory of neutral states; cause long-term and widespread damage to 
the environment or use poisonous substances.

Most war tax resisters redirect their withheld federal tax funds to outfits 
such as the Conscience and Military Tax Campaign Escrow Account in Seattle. 
This way, the money is still on hand, if they should ever be forced to fork 
it over. Though getting a notice from the Internal Revenue Service is 
likely, jail is uncommon for war tax resisters. Still, there are no 

IRS public affairs officer Ken Vargas of the Austin, Texas, office of the 
IRS explains the collections office sends out "soft notices" first, 
followed by "harder notices" later. Vargas says the IRS doesn't keep a 
handy record of war tax resisters. He insists "normal collection 
procedures" apply to all subjects, regardless of whether they write letters 
stating their war tax resistance. In fact, the tax reform act of 1998 makes 
it illegal for the IRS to designate tax protesters as a special class.

Susan Quinlan, a Bay Area organizer for the National War Tax Resistance 
Coordinating Committee, pegs the number of war tax resisters who have 
seriously faced jail time at less than 20 over the past 50 years. It 
doesn't necessarily have to be your income tax that you use for protesting, 

One of the first federal taxes to spark opposition was the federal phone 
tax. This tax has been in existence since 1914. Originally introduced as a 
"temporary" tax, after 76 years Congress made it permanent and set its 
level at 3 percent of your phone bill. Protesters simply include a note 
saying that they refuse to pay their federal excise tax for conscientious 
purposes and pay the rest.

Resistance to the telephone tax has a long and distinguished history, and 
most phone companies will put up no fight to customers who will not pay it. 
Perhaps they're just as happy not to serve as unpaid tax collectors for the 

In any event, tax resister groups estimate that tens of thousands of 
Americans don't pay their income taxes in order to protest U.S.-backed war 
efforts around the world. And, they say, that number is growing every year.
For updates and info, contact scott at planttrees dot org.