Food and ad industry warned to stop targeting children
06/04/2005 - Democrat Senator Tom Harkin yesterday sent a strong message to
the food industry, saying that it must move swiftly to stop the advertising
aimed at children that was creating a "botched" generation.
His speech was given at a joint conference of the American Advertising
Federation, the American Association of Advertising Agencies and the
Association of National Advertisers.
Harkin made it clear to the advertisers that if they did nothing to reduce
or even stop advertising to children, then the only way forward would be to
“When it comes to the advertising and marketing of food to children, it is
still my hope that real restraint will come from within your
industry...obviating the need for further federal regulation," he said.
It is well documented that America is in the grip of an obesity crisis,
Harkin said that 15 percent of American children and teenagers are obese,
"a higher rate than in any other industrialized country". However, he said
that there was added urgency to do something with new evidence that today’s
young generation could be the first to suffer a shorter lifespan than the
one that preceded it.
“The alarms are going off, one after another. Yet, we keep hitting the
He said that inactivity and poor nutrition were together contributing to
the obesity crisis, but that children were consuming more calories and more
foods high in sugar, fat, and salt because they taste good, are available
everywhere and are "being aggressively advertised and marketed".
He added : “Corporate America...spends $12 billion [on advertising aimed at
children] because that advertising works brilliantly because it persuades
children to demand – to the point of throwing temper tantrums, if necessary
– a regular diet of candy, cookies, sugary cereal, sodas, and all manner of
Children under the age of eight are unable to tell the difference between a
TV program and a commercial and parents should not have to sit there
watching children’s shows to check whether there are any offending ads,
“Not even schools are safe havens anymore. There is Channel One, with ads
for candy bars and sugary sodas. There are giant Coke machines that double
as billboards, right in the school hallway or cafeteria."
He cited a Wall Street Journal poll from February that had found that 68
percent of American adults believe that advertising to kids is a major
contributor to the rising tide of obesity in children and that a clear
majority said government should do more to regulate food ads directed at
Stephanie Childs from the Grocery Manufacturers of America recently told
FoodNavigatorUSA.com that she believed that most food companies practised
responsible advertising that complies with the Children’s Advertising
Review Unit (CARU), meaning that, for example, if a snack is being
advertised the "right size serving is shown in the right context".
Harkin admitted that the "CARU has done some good things" and was at least
an acknowledgement by the advertising industry that irresponsible food
marketing to children is a very real problem, but he did not think that it
went far enough.
"CARU is not cutting it. It has no legal authority – and it has no teeth."
Harkin wants the advertising industry to sit down with the food and
broadcasting companies to "hammer out tough, rigorous, age-appropriate
standards to govern the marketing of junk food to children. And create an
enforcement body that has independence and teeth."
The senator had already announced last month that he planned to propose a
bill enabling the FTC to regulate food advertising to children.
"The Harkin bill would restore the FTC’s power to regulate advertising for
children - taken away during the cavity epidemic of the 1980s to save food
companies from suffering restrications - but it would be up to the FTC to
decide how and what to regulate," Allison Dobson, Harkin's spokeswoman,
explained to FoodNavigatorUSA.com.
She added at the time that Harkin also planned to table a second bill,
which would allow the secretary of agriculture to prohibit junk food
advertising in schools.
The ban on food advertising to children is a stance supported by the Center
for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) that has already drawn up
guidelines suggesting that only "products that may not be nutritionally
ideal but that provide some positive nutritional benefit and that could
help children meet the dietary guidelines" should be advertised to children.
"Companies should not conduct general brand marketing aimed at children for
brands under which more than half of the products are of poor nutritional
quality," believes the organization.
Michael Jacobson, executive director of the CSPI, added: "Ideally the food
manufacturers should limit their advertising, but they can’t control
themselves. Therefore, it will fall to government to come up with some rules".
The GMA, on the other hand, naturally takes a less rigid approach,
affirming that steps are already in place to make sure children see only
the right sort of advertising and thinks it is nonsense to suggest children
upto the age of 18 need to be protected from food advertising.
"We do not support a ban on advertising food products. A ban would not be
the right solution," said Childs. Instead, she said that the organization
would be looking at what is working in then present system and building on
Dobson admitted that there were ongoing improvements in the food industry,
but felt they were "small steps". "If they had happened 10 years ago they
might have brought us somewhere," she said, adding that more drastic action
The GMA, however, believes that the food industry is taking huge steps
forward. "GMA members have introduced thousands of new and reformulated
products that are lower in saturated and trans fats, sodium and sugar,"
said Manly Molpus, CEO of the GMA.
Unless otherwise stated all contents of this web site are © 2000/2005–
NOVIS. – All Rights Reserved.
For permission to reproduce any contents of this web site, please email our
our Syndication department
Full details for the use of materials on this site can be found in the
Food and ad industry warned to stop targeting children
For information on aspartame which targets children and can trigger birth
defects, mental retardation, behavioral problems and reduce IQ see
http://www.dorway.com and http://www.wnho.net Aspartame has a synergistic
and additive effect with MSG, http://www.truthinlabeling.org and interacts with
all drugs. As a chemical hypersensitization agent interacts with vaccines
and other unsafe sweeteners like Splenda, a chlorinated hydrocarbon and
other toxins. Join the Aspartame Information List, on www.wnho.net and
see the movie on Aspartame - Sweet Misery: A Poisoned World -
Dr. Betty Martini, Founder, Mission Possible Intl, 9270 River Club Parkway,
Duluth, Georgia 30097 770 242-2599 http://www.dorway.com and